Frederick Arthur Branch Describes
Materializations Under Oath

Helen Duncan

Old Bailey Courtroom
Witness: Frederick Arthur Branch
Defense attorney: We have had all that, Mr. Branch. Tell me of anything in regard to your- self. Did someone appear for you personally?
Frederick Branch: Yes, my grand- mother.
Defense attorney: Did she come close to you?
Frederick Branch: I went over to her, but she came half-way.
Defense attorney: About how close did you get to her?
Frederick Branch: To within about a foot of her.
Defense attorney: What did you see?
Frederick Branch: The height of her was about to my shoulder; she was very slenderly built, and I saw hundreds of wrinkles upon her face.
Defense attorney: Would she answer the description of a little old lady?
Frederick Branch: Yes.
Defense attorney: Did she speak?
Frederick Branch: Yes.
Defense attorney: Did you notice the accent she spoke in?
Frederick Branch: Yes, sir, a Suffolk accent, very similar to mine, but a soft voice.
Defense attorney: Yours is not a Suffolk accent, is it?
Frederick Branch: No.
Defense attorney: Yours is an Essex accent?
Frederick Branch: Yes.
Defense attorney: You spoke to her with an Essex accent, and she answered you with a Suffolk accent?
Frederick Branch: Yes.
Defense attorney: Could you imitate the Suffolk accent?
Judge: It is not much good, because the jury may not recognize it.
Defense attorney: Did you recognize the Suffolk accent?
Frederick Branch: Yes.
Defense attorney: And she spoke to you with a Suffolk accent?
Frederick Branch: Yes.
Defense attorney: Was it a stout figure, or a slender figure?
Frederick Branch: A slender figure.
Defense attorney: Could you indicate the height with your hand?
Frederick Branch: Up to my shoulder, sir.
Defense attorney: Apart from the fact that she had wrinkles which does not amount to much you could not confirm that it was your grandmother, could you?
Frederick Branch: No, but that was confirmed to me by my mother a fortnight later when I went back.
Defense attorney: You did not know your grandmother yourself, did you?
Frederick Branch: No, sir.
Defense attorney: But you did notice that she had wrinkles?
Frederick Branch: Yes.
Judge: You are satisfied it was your grandmother?
Frederick Branch: Yes, my Lord.
Prosecuting attorney: What did your grannie say to you?
Frederick Branch: My grandmother said, “Hullo, Fred; don’t worry. I am watching over you”.
Prosecuting attorney: No more?
Frederick Branch: No more.
Prosecuting attorney: Did you say anything?
Frederick Branch: Yes, I called her out of the cabinet.
Prosecuting attorney: Did you see the curtains move?
Frederick Branch: Yes.
Prosecuting attorney: Was she all in white?
Frederick Branch: Yes.
Prosecuting attorney: Did she go back into the cabinet?
Frederick Branch: No, sir.
Prosecuting attorney: What happened?
Frederick Branch: She disappeared through the floor.
Judge: Was it something white?
Frederick Branch: Yes.
Prosecuting attorney: How far was she out of the cabinet?
Frederick Branch: About two feet.
Prosecuting attorney: Did you hear Albert speak?
Frederick Branch: Yes.
Prosecuting attorney: What sort of accent did he have?
Frederick Branch: I should say it would be the Oxford accent; a very cultured voice.